The World According to Nick
Politics, News, Photography, and Triathlons... What don't I talk about?
Tuesday, October 02, 2007
<< Thank God for a Weak Division Staring Is Allowed... It's a Good Cause >>
What Do You Think They Teach In School?

So I was reading Eugene's latest column, and it got me thinking... what exactly are they teaching in school these days?  Based on the examples of culture bias in standardized tests that he gave, I'm suspecting that high school is a lot more like some of the electives they teach at the UW system then when I remember going to high school:

When some people talk about cultural bias in standardized testing, this is what they mean:

What popular 1990s TV show starred hip-hop star Queen Latifah?
...
Whatever the reason, these children experience circumstances and situations few white children have to deal with.

What does "5-0" mean?

What high school class teaches that stuff Eugene?  Introduction to Television Studies?  Do those questions actually appear on standardized tests, or did you just need to think up something that a black person might know that a white person might not?  Let's really talk about this.  When talking about math, cultural bias ought not enter into the equation.  2+2 should equal 4 whether you're white or black.  I'd say the same goes for science.  You're either learning the material or you're not.  Ionic and covalent bonds don't react differently in a beaker based on the skin color of the hand holding it.

So what does that leave us?  Critical reading.  Most standardized tests that I remember were based on a simple premise.  Read some blurb, and then answer questions based on that blurb.  Could there be culture bias built into those sample reading sections?  Now I suppose it's possible that the section may not be written to be as interesting, or fun, to a black person compared to a white person, but then again, I never remember a standardized test to be fun at all.  And whether it's interesting or not, that shouldn't affect your ability to answer the questions.

So before you claim cultural bias, why don't you give us an example for a real test that shows real bias, instead of pulling examples from your ass that doesn't prove a damn thing.

# Posted at 11:08 AM by Nick  |  Comment Feed Link 5 Comments  |  No Trackbacks

 Add to del.icio.us |  Digg this Post | Filed Under: Politics

Tuesday, October 02, 2007 3:32:51 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
Was Latifah a princess when she was younger?

5.0 is the volumetric displacement, in liters, of the 302 cubic inch V8 engine used until recently in the Ford Mustang. Next question?
Tuesday, October 02, 2007 3:52:58 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
I thought the same thing when I read that. But that's because Eugene is an idiot. And just because he's an idiot doesn't mean his point is wrong. I believe his argument is wrong, but I've heard others make his point better. I still thought they were overblowing it, but I didn't think they were idiots like Eugene. I'm about to make shit up too, but I think the typical examples are things like:

Pitcher is to baseball game as coxswain is to:

A) football
B) regatta
C) crew
D) drag Racing

This is a flawed example since many white suburban kids don't know what the hell a coxswain or a regatta is either, but you get the idea. The question is intended to see if the test taker will see that the question wants you to relate a "position" in a sport (pitcher/coxswain) with the name of a the competition in that sport (baseball game/regatta). Some test takers might miss it if they associated the "position" with the sport (crew) instead of the competition (regatta). It would be culturally biased, so the argument goes, because there is a slim chance that a kid who went to high school in the inner city had a crew team.
jesusisjustalrightwithme
Tuesday, October 02, 2007 3:57:07 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
I see your point jiawm... but I think your example is fairly limited to that type of question, which don't generally appear in academic proficiency tests, which is really the subject of Eugene's column. I think you tend to see them more in IQ tests, where the goal isn't to test against a standard set of knowledge, but rather a type of thinking.
Tuesday, October 02, 2007 4:41:02 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
Yeah, that's all I could come up with on the spot. I do think Kane is wrong, but I don't think he's as wrong as he sounds. You do see those kinds of questions in some standardized tests you take in lower grades though, if not on the SAT and ACT.
jesusisjustalrightwithme
Tuesday, October 02, 2007 10:22:00 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
Oh shoot, I knew what a coxswain and a regatta was. Is there something wrong with me?
Comments are closed.


© Copyright 2009 Nick Schweitzer
Powered By newtelligence dasBlog 1.9.7067.0
Theme Based on Design By maystar