Bohr, by contrast, seemed to dismiss many questions about quantum as altogether meaningless, analogous to asking: "What color is up?"
In Howard's view, Bohr, far from being intentionally mystical in his replies, was merely being careful. If Howard is right, the nature of Bohr's caution is perfectly described by an anecdote many people will have heard in different forms. In my version, a child, a physicist, and a philosopher are traveling in a train passing through a country none of them has previously visited. The train passes a field in which they see a black sheep."Wow," says the child, "look at that. All of the sheep in this country are black!"The physicist smiles. "We don't know that," he says. "All we can really tell is that some of the sheep in this country are black."The philosopher smiles. "We don't know that," he says. "All we really know is that at least one sheep in this country appears black on at least one side!"
Disclaimer The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.